December/January Cases Certified to Disciplinary Board
The Ohio Board of Professional Conduct today announced the certification of 17 cases in December and January for formal disciplinary proceedings.
In each case, a certified complaint has been sent to the respondent, and the respondent has been directed to file an answer to the allegations contained in the complaint. Once an answer is received, the case will be assigned to a three-member hearing panel of the board, and the hearing panel will conduct further proceedings in the case. If the respondent does not answer the allegations, the respondent’s failure to answer will be certified to the Ohio Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court may suspend the respondent’s license to practice law.
Typically, a public hearing is scheduled within four to six months after the case is assigned to a hearing panel. Please consult the Upcoming Hearings Schedule for a monthly list of board hearings.
If the board finds that a lawyer or judge has engaged in professional misconduct, the board will file a report with the Court that includes a recommended sanction. The Court is responsible for reviewing the board report and case record and imposing discipline.
To access the complaints in these cases, click on the individual case numbers below.
Mahoning County Bar Association v. Mark Immanuel Verkhlin
Case No. 2016-062
Respondent’s counsel: None
Cincinnati Bar Association v. Neal Allen May
      Case No. 2016-063
      Respondent’s counsel: None
Mahoning County Bar Association v. Neal Ghaleb Atway
      Case No. 2016-064
      Respondent’s counsel: John B. Juhasz Jr., Youngstown and Lynn A. Maro, Boardman
Disciplinary Counsel v. Clyde Bennett II
      Case No. 2016-065
      Respondent’s counsel: George D. Jonson, Cincinnati
Disciplinary Counsel v. Robert Kolter Leonard
      Case No. 2016-066
      Respondent’s counsel: None
Disciplinary Counsel v. Trent Reynard Turner
      Case No. 2016-067
      Respondent’s counsel: Richard F. Chambers II, Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. Samuel Ray Smith II
      Case No. 2016-068
      Respondent’s counsel: Alvin E. Mathews Jr., Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. John Walter Gold
      Case No. 2016-069
      Respondent’s counsel: None
Disciplinary Counsel v. Cynthia Ann Williams
  Case No. 2016-070
      Respondent’s counsel: Jonathan E. Coughlan, Columbus
Columbus Bar Association v. Bradley Dennis Keating
      Case No. 2016-071
      Respondent’s counsel: Alvin E. Mathews Jr., Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. Rufus Sims
      Case No. 2016-072
      Respondent’s counsel: Mary L. Cibella, Cleveland
Disciplinary Counsel v. John Edward Patterson
      Case No. 2016-073
      Respondent’s counsel: Alvin E. Mathews Jr., Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. Paul Anthony Mancino Jr
      Case No. 2016-074
      Respondent’s counsel: None
Disciplinary Counsel v. Timothy Raymond Dougherty
      Case No. 2016-075
      Respondent’s counsel: Ric Daniell, Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. Mark Alan Deters
      Case No. 2016-076
      Respondent’s counsel: Alvin E. Mathews Jr., Columbus
Disciplinary Counsel v. Christopher J. Goldthorpe
      Case No. 2016-077
      Respondent’s counsel: Larry H. James, Columbus
Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Rosel Charles Hurley III
      Case No. 2017-001
      Respondent’s counsel: None
Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association v. Matthew Joseph King
      Case No. 2017-002
Respondent’s counsel: None
Acrobat Reader is a trademark of Adobe Systems Incorporated.


