Toledo Law School Hosts Appeals Court Oral Arguments

Sixth District Presiding Judge Thomas Osowik (center) and Judges Christine Mayle and Charles Sulek field questions from law students at a special off-site visit to a law school.
The Sixth District Court of Appeals gave students at the University of Toledo College of Law a special treat in late October. The appeals court judges held oral arguments at the law school, instead of the courthouse, giving more than 100 first-year law students the chance to watch an appellate court in action.
Judges Thomas J. Osowik, Christine E. Mayle, and Charles E. Sulek heard three cases during the court’s special off-site session on Oct. 30. The appeals involved a defamation claim made by a former Port Clinton fire chief, a dispute between an Ottawa County restaurant and the landlord, and a foreclosure on a Perrysburg property.
“We hoped to expose students to the appellate court system and offer them the chance to watch real lawyers argue real cases,” said Court Administrator Jason Hill, who is also a magistrate for the court. “It’s a good civics and real-world introduction to the appellate courts.”
Hill explained that the cases also showed the students the different standards of legal review and the appellate court’s role when evaluating trial court actions.
The event was notable for another reason, as it marked the final oral arguments for Judge Osowik before he retires in January 2027. Judge Osowik, a 1981 graduate of the Toledo law school, has served as a judge in Lucas County for more than 35 years. Voters have reelected him to the Sixth District multiple times since they first elected him to the appeals court in 2006. He has served as the court’s presiding judge since January of this year.
At the event, students had the opportunity to ask the judges questions. The judges shared their thoughts about their career backgrounds, tips for advocacy, and navigating careers in the law. The court’s extern program was also explained to the law students.
The Sixth District decides appeals from trial courts across Erie, Fulton, Huron, Lucas, Ottawa, Sandusky, Williams, and Wood counties. Appellate cases are heard and decided by a three-judge panel from the five elected judges who serve on the Sixth District, which includes Judges Myron Duhart and Gene Zmuda along with Presiding Judge Osowik and Judges Mayle and Sulek.
Courts are encouraged to share news of events, initiatives, programs, and other announcements with Court News Ohio. Ideas can be submitted to CNO@sc.ohio.gov.